Agefi Luxembourg - novembre 2026

AGEFI Luxembourg 38 Novembre 2026 RH & Droit T he EuropeanCommissionpre­ sented a newregulatory proposal, theRetail investment Strategy (the “RIS”), forwhich a provisional agree­ ment between theCouncil of the Euro­ peanUnion and the EuropeanParliament was reached on 18December 2025, aimed atmodifying the current legal framework to promote the transparency of information for re­ tail investors. Its formal adoption by the EuropeanParliament is ex­ pectedbyQ4 2026, andpublica­ tion in theOfficial Journal by January 2027 at the latest.Mem­ ber Stateswill thenhave 24months to transpose the omnibus directive, and the application of themeasures is expectedby the end of the first half of 2029. Newperspectives on financial advisory: VFM Among the objectives pursued, the RIS plans to strengthen the value of products with the notion of ValueforMoney(“ VFM ”),whichwillrequiretaking into account costs but also performance and results/benefitsforclients,andtowhichitwillbenec­ essarytocomparethestrengthsandweaknesses of theproductswith those of themarket. Retail investment firms will be required to identify and quantify all costs and expenses incurred byinvestorsinrelationtotheinvestmentprod­ ucts they advise upon. (1) Moreover, VFM considerations will need to be inserted into the product gov­ ernance framework and to accu­ rately trace investment processes anddecisions. The suitability test already carried out by these firms under existing legislation ensures that clients are recom­ mended investment products that are tailored to their financial situation, needs, and objectives. This allowsinvestmentproductstobematchedtoindi­ vidual profiles and provides safeguards against unsuitable offers. (2) In addition, the RIS plans to adapt the distribution and advisory models by identifying inducements and conflicts of interest related to the distribution model, by introducing stronger rules on incentives – fees, commissions, and monetary or nonmonetary benefitsreceivedbyaninvestmentfirminconnection with investment services it provides toa client. Itwill also require a refocusing of advisory models to the client interest by changing the professional require­ ments of the financial sector. Intermsoftransparencyofinformationandcommu­ nication, it is expected that existing documentation will be overhauled with a simplification of product descriptions, and that datawill beused tocontrol the risksandneedsofthecustomer.Investmentinforma­ tion regarding costs, risks and expected returns will bemademore visible and accessible to consumers. (3) The updated framework will allow more retail in­ vestors to be treated as professional clients. However, these investors will need to meet two of the following three criteria to be considered pro­ fessionals (4) : (i) they have carried out fifteen significant transac­ tions in the last three years, thirty transactions in the previous year, or ten transactions of more than EUR 30,000 in unlisted companies in the last five years (in the current legislation, this criterion currently pro­ vides for ten transactions per quarter in the previous four quarters); (ii)thesizeoftheirportfoliohasexceeded€250,000on average over the last three years (currently €500,000 at the time of their exemption application); or (iii) they have worked and carried out related ac­ tivities in the financial sector for at least one year or, under a newalternative criterion, they can pro­ vide evidence that they have received education or training related to those activities and are able to assess risks. However, the alternative training andeducation cri­ terion in (iii) cannot be combinedwith the portfolio criterion in (ii) in order for an investor to benefit from an exemption. The text also pays particular attention to the activi­ ties of financial influencers, or “finfluencers”, who sometimes offer unsuitable financial advice anddo not always comply with the legal and regulatory framework in force. Lastly, the dedicated compliance departments will need to follow the legal changes and the clarifica­ tions providedby the soft lawinorder to anticipate the regulatory compliance requirements to be im­ plemented. The text will amend the requirements related to MIFID II, PRIIPS, IDD etc. and will cer­ tainlyhave a significant impact on investment com­ pliance framework. Nessym Jules TIR, Avocat/Partner, Compliance & Internal Investigations, Wolff & Partners SCS, Attorneys at law 1 )https://urls.fr/s7WMPb 2 )https://urls.fr/yUeuZ 3 )https://urls.fr/AGTdnl 4)Ibid Retail Investor Strategy: Compliance in the service of retail investor protection I n April 2026, the Luxembourg go­ vernment announced plans to create specialized chambers for economic and financial matters. Submitted to Par­ liament on 12 May 2026 as bill 8748 (the “Bill”), the proposal esta­ blishes commercial and crimi­ nal chambers at both the Luxembourg District Court and the Court of Appeal, alongside criminal chambers at the Diekirch District Court. Currently under parliamentary ex­ amination, the file was most recently updated on 20 October 2026. (1)(2) Subject to the Bill’s adoption, these specialized chambers are ex­ pected to open on 16 September 2027. For the Luxembourg financial center, this initiative is awelcome step forward. The proposal recognizes that complexdisputes require sustained familiarity, not only with the law, but also with the financial arrangements it governs and the relatedaccounting treatments. The commercial chamber in Luxem­ bourg would hold exclusive nationwide jurisdic­ tion over specific matters, including certain disputes involving investment funds, securitization and financial guarantees. The Bill also proposes nine additional judicial posts and ongoing training for specialized judges in eco­ nomicandfinancial law, accounting, financial analy­ sis andEnglish legal terminology. (3) Building on existing judicial expertise TheBillisnotacritiqueofthejudgescurrentlyhearing these cases. Luxembourg’s courts already deal with sophisticatedcommercialandfinancialdisputes.Inits opinion on the Bill, the Superior Court of Justice em­ phasized that many magistrates possess expertise in economic and financial matters and deliver high­ qualitydecisions.Theproposedreformbuildsonthis foundation by giving relevant experience a defined placewithin the jurisdiction’s organization. (4) That continuity matters in practice. Adispute over a fundor a securitizationvehiclemay require the court to bridge governing documents, contractual obliga­ tionsandtheeconomicrealityofatransaction.Famil­ iarity with these structures can help a judge identify the core questions and assess the evidence presented by both sides.While it cannot determine a case’s out­ come,itcansupportamoreconsistentapproachtore­ curring technical issues. The Bill also streamlines case management by intro­ ducing a preparatory hearing to agree on timetables. Crucially, it expressly permits the production of ex­ hibits in English during specified commercial pro­ ceedings,reflectingtherealityofcrossborderfinancial documentation. However, English will not become the official language of the proceedings. The precise treatment of Englishlanguage exhibits, particularly wheretheirmeaningiscontested,mayrequirefurther clarificationduring the legislative process. (5) Aseparate path for tax disputes Taxpayers should note an important distinction: the Bill does not create a tax court or transfer direct tax disputes to the proposed financial chambers. These disputes remain within the administrative jurisdic­ tions’perimeter. Although the Bill amends legislation governing ad­ ministrative courts, these changes focus onorganiza­ tional matters and oathtaking, not court jurisdiction overtaxdisputes.TheAdministrativeCourtexplicitly describestheproposedfinancialchambersasadevel­ opmentwithinLuxembourg’sjudicialorder(ordreju­ diciaire) rather than its administrative court system. (6) Separately, tax litigation is developing its own spe­ cializationprocess.Atthebeginningofthe2023–2024 judicialyear,theAdministrativeTribunalestablished afifthchamberprincipallydedicated todirect tax lit­ igation. The Administrative Tribunal described the initialexperienceasbroadlypositive (7) whilestressing the importance of retaining judges’ ability to hear other types of cases. The broader trend is clearer at the administrative level. According to the Luxembourg direct tax au­ thorities (Administrationdes contributions directes, or ACD ) (8) , thenumber of newobjections and formal hierarchical appeals submitted to its directorwas 44 percent higher in 2025 than in 2016, despite a slight decline from2024.While thesefiguresdonot predict howmany caseswill reach a court, they underscore theneed tomaintain tax expertise across thedispute resolution process. In parallel, theOrganization for Economic Cooper­ ation and Development’s Base Erosion and Profit Shifting 2.0 project is reshaping the international tax landscape toward a coordinated global minimum tax.At its core, thePillar Two framework establishes rulesdesigned toensure that largemultinational en­ terprises are subject to aminimumeffective tax rate of 15 percent on their profits in each jurisdiction where they operate. On 22 December 2023, Luxembourg published the law transposing the EUPillar TwoDirective into do­ mestic law (the “ Pillar Two Law” ). The Pillar Two Law introduces rules to tax large multinational and domestic groups with consolidated revenues of EUR750million or more (in at least two of the past fouryears)ataminimumrateof15percent,apply­ inga“topuptax”tobridgeanyshortfall.Thisrep­ resents a significant change to the existing tax frameworkforLuxembourg,aswellasforthemore than 100 other jurisdictions involved. Pillar Two adds a significant layer of com­ plexity and tests existing expertise. Its calculations draw on financial ac­ counting information and require groups to apply detailed rules across entities and jurisdictions. Under­ standing complex accounting treat­ ments under different financial accounting standards and consolida­ tion challenges is now an absolute must. This is completely new to the tax world in general, and to Luxembourg inparticular. The ACD’s June 2026 guidance (9) offers a glimpse of this complexity. Its worked examples address who must file, how a transitional safe harbor af­ fects filing obligations andwhich Luxembourg en­ tity is allocated the topup tax. Differences over underlying data or the rule applications may eventually lead to challenges. By midJuly 2026, the first Pillar Two filings re­ ported approximately EUR225 million in Luxem­ bourg tax liabilities. Although this is a preliminary figure based on taxpayers’ declarations (i.e. not an amount arising from tax reassessments), (10) it illus­ trates the magnitude of the sums at stake. With these initial returns now lodged, the number and size of tax controversy cases could increase signifi­ cantly in the months and years ahead. (11) While it is too early to assess how many disputes these newrulesmaygenerate, their complexity and the legal uncertainty surrounding certain aspects of their application could lead to an increase in tax controversy. Legal certainty also depends on clarifying tax posi­ tions before disputes develop.Advance tax decisions remain available for specific proposed transactions under an established legal framework. The ACD recorded47decisions (including favorable andunfa­ vorable outcomes) in 2025, up from 32 in 2024.(12) That increase is notable, though it stands in contrast to the 95 decisions recorded in 2019. (13) The director of the ACD, JeanPaul Olinger, has ex­ pressly identified advance decisions, alongside clear legislation and published guidance, as ways to im­ prove the predictability of tax outcomes. (14) Advance decisions cannot resolve every question, but clearer guidanceandearlydialoguecanhelpbusinessesiden­ tify uncertainty before it becomes a disagreement. Against this background, the current limitations aroundobtainingadvancetaxdecisionsonPillarTwo may create additional uncertainty for taxpayers. What businesses candonow Specialized judges donot remove the need for busi­ nesses to present a clear, wellsupported case. When valuation is at issue, parties must be able to explain theirmethodology andassumptions. If a fi­ nancial or tax calculation is central to a dispute, it must be traceable to its underlying data. For Pillar Two, this includes reconciling the relevant financial statement data with the tax calculation and docu­ menting the basis for any safe harbor position. Ac­ counting records, contractual documents and expert reports should tell a coherent story, rather than leaving it to the courts to reconcile them. The practical lesson is to preserve the reasoning be­ hind significant decisions and calculations while the relevant people and information are still available. This applies equally to a commercial dispute over a financial structure and to a potential disagreement with the tax authorities. It does not mean every case requires a valuation report or an expert witness: the evidence shouldfit the questionbeingdecided. Inourview,Luxembourg’sproposedfinancialcham­ bersdeservesupportforwhattheyare:awaytobuild on existing judicial expertise in complex commercial and criminalmatters. They are not a reformof tax lit­ igation. For tax disputes, the parallel path is to con­ tinuedevelopingthespecializationalreadyunderway in the Administrative Tribunal, while strengthening the guidance, dialogue anddocumentation thatmay prevent disputes from arising in the first place. To­ gether, these steps serve the same vital objective: achieving greater legal certainty for businesses oper­ ating inLuxembourg. EmilienLEBAS,Partner,HeadofInternationalTax, Taxcontroversy&disputeresolution leader, SylvainRABOUINE,SeniorTaxAdviser,InternationalTax, KPMGLuxembourg 1)LuxembourgGovernment,“Résumédestravauxdu15avril2026,” 15April2026;Chambredesdéputés,parliamentaryfilen°8748. 2)LuxembourgChamberofDeputies,“ParliamentaryfileNo.8748,” accessed09November2026. 3)LuxembourgParliament,Billn°8748,explanatorymemorandum, Articles1,3and5,andrelatedcommentary. 4)SuperiorCourtofJustice,“AvisdelaCoursupérieuredeJusticesur leprojetdeloinuméro8748”,2026,pp.1–2. 5)NationalCouncilfortheJudiciary,« Avisdu Conseilnationalde la justice » onBillNo.8748,22July2026,pp.45(inFrench). 6) Administrative Court, “ Avis de la Cour administrative ” on Bill No. 8748, 15 June 2026, p. 1; LuxembourgChamber of Deputies, Bill No. 8748, document de dépôt, draftArticle 5 and related commentary (bothinFrench). 7)AdministrativeCourtandAdministrativeTribunal,“Rapportsre­ latifsaufonctionnementdelaCouradministrative(annéecivile2024) et du tribunal administratif (année judiciaire 2023–2024)”, 2025, pp. 17–18(inFrench). 8)Administrationdescontributionsdirectes(ACD),“Rapportd’acti­ vité2025”,“Activitécontentieuse,”p.167(inFrench). 9)Administrationdescontributionsdirectes(ACD),“Foireauxques­ tions(FAQ)–Loi«Pilier2»”,versionof17June2026,pp.7–9and16– 17(inFrench). 10) Ioanna Schimizzi, “Déjà plus de 225millions d’euros déclarés au titreduPilier2”,Paperjam,4August2026(inFrench). 11) For a detailed analysis of Luxembourg’s Pillar Two compliance obligations, see Emilien Lebas and Eduardo Gutierrez Hernandez, “Global minimum tax rules in Luxembourg: new compliance obli­ gations”, Revue générale de fiscalité luxembourgeoise, No. 2025/3, Larcier(inEnglish). 12)Administrationdescontributionsdirectes(ACD),“Rapportd’ac­ tivité2025”,pp.121and123(inFrench). 13)Administrationdescontributionsdirectes(ACD),“Rapportd’ac­ tivité2020”,p.125(inFrench). 14)JeanPaulOlinger,interview,“JeanPaulOlinger(Administration des contributions directes) : les taxes luxembourgeoises à l’heure du digital,”AndyàLuxembourg,No.37(inFrench). Luxembourg tax update: Financial courts and the next test for tax justice

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy Nzk5MDI=